Why Solid Cancers Are Harder To Treat
Unlike blood cancers, which exist in a fluid medium that systemically-administered drugs can permeate, solid tumors establish formidable barriers impeding drug delivery. Poor drug penetration results from abnormal tumor blood vessels, high interstitial pressure collapsing vessels, hypoxia, acidity from localized metabolites, tight cell junctions, and active drug efflux pumps in cancer cell membranes. Additional obstacles include tumor cell diversity with mixed susceptible and resistant cell populations, cancer stem cells that evade therapies, protective stromal cells, binding proteins that sequester drugs, and modified drug metabolism pathways. This multifaceted pathophysiology allows only a tiny fraction of drugs to reach and effectively act on all cancer cells, enabling resistance. Advancing solutions from multiple angles including optimized drug development, delivery techniques, modifiers of tumor physiology, and combination therapies is imperative to overcome these challenges unique to eradicating solid cancers.
The Complex Obstacles Hindering Drug Delivery in Solid Tumors
When a cancer drug is injected into the bloodstream, it faces an uphill battle reaching its target. Imagine running a marathon on a twisting, jam-packed highway riddled with construction detours. This begins to portray the immense challenges drugs encounter penetrating deep into solid tumors.
Research shows that only about 0.7% of the administered drug dose actually reaches the tumor site. The rest continues circulating throughout the body, exposing patients to toxic side effects. It’s like haphazardly spraying a tiny garden weed with a wide-arc industrial hose - not very efficient or effective. But getting drugs to the tumor is only half the battle - they also need to permeate every inch of the growth. As tumors expand, their blood vessels become strikingly disorganized and dysfunctional, with blocked off or collapsed vessels creating oxygen-starved zones. Studies show up to 90% of a tumor’s total volume ends up scarcely reached by drugs at all. This leaves large areas untouched by treatment, enabling resistance and recurrence.
So what are the key obstacles drugs face entering and diffusing throughout tumors? For starters, the vessels feeding tumors are structurally and functionally abnormal. Imaging reveals tortuous, dilated, and leaky vessels that prevent uniform drug delivery. This irregular vasculature results from dysregulated angiogenesis driven by factors secreted by cancer cells. Additionally, the interstitial pressure inside tumors is markedly elevated, further collapsing blood vessels and impeding drug penetration into the tissue.
Areas of low oxygen tension, or hypoxia, are common deep within tumors due to the oxygen demands of rapidly proliferating cancer cells outpacing supply. Hypoxic zones create an environment that reduces the efficacy of some chemotherapy drugs. Making matters worse is the reversed pH gradient - blood is alkaline, while the tumor microenvironment is highly acidic. This causes chemotherapy agents like doxorubicin to become trapped in their charged form, preventing their diffusion.
At the cellular level, tight junctions between cancer cells create a physical barrier inhibiting large molecule drugs from passing between cells. Active efflux pumps in tumor cell membranes compound this by ejecting drugs from cells before they can exert their desired cytotoxic effects. Multidrug resistance transporters like MDR1 are a major mediator of chemoresistance.
Cancer cells also hijack the body’s natural drug metabolism pathways to inactivate medicines. They overproduce certain proteins that chemotherapies nonspecifically bind to rather than their intended targets. All these mechanisms enable tumors to mount a multifaceted defense against drugs reaching their shielded inner sanctum.
Making matters more difficult, tumors are complex ecosystems containing a diversity of cell subpopulations and stromal components. This heterogeneity means no single chemotherapy drug can tackle every feature at once. Cancer stem cells add another vexing wrinkle - they are often more resistant to treatment and can later regenerate the tumor, much like the mythological hydra growing new heads.
Another barrier is the real-time blinding of drug uptake. Unlike antibiotics where we can culture bacteria to ensure efficacy, measuring drug penetration into tumors during treatment is not readily feasible. This makes it tremendously difficult to actively adapt dosing to optimize delivery. Researchers are pursuing new imaging techniques and biomarkers to address this gap.
In total, the pathophysiology of tumors erects both biochemical and physical barricades that severely hinder drug delivery. With so many roadblocks on the route from blood vessel to cancer cell, it is remarkable chemotherapy is effective at all. But evolution has taught cancer cells every trick in the book for developing resistance and blocking access to their inner sanctum. Perfecting regimens to overcome these manifold obstacles remains one of the great challenges in cancer care. But this mountain is surmountable through step-wise improvements guided by scientific insights into the formidable defense systems of cancer.
A Multifaceted Solution to Solving the Drug Delivery Dilemma
While formidable obstacles impede drug delivery in solid tumors, creative solutions from many angles hold promise to turn the tide. One approach aims to remodel the abnormal tumor vasculature using judicious anti-angiogenic therapies. The goal is to prune only the immature, leaky vessels while retaining mature blood vessels capable of improving perfusion. Agents like bevacizumab are being explored to normalize the tumor vascular network. Other medications constrict blood vessels, counteracting the high interstitial pressure inside tumors that collapses vessels and blocks drug penetration.
At the cellular level, nanoparticles - tiny drug loaded particles - are demonstrating potential to enhance tumor delivery. Their nano size helps concentrate drugs in tumors by passive accumulation in leaky vasculature and poor lymphatic drainage. Active targeting by attaching tumor-specific ligands provides another level of specificity. Encapsulating chemotherapy drugs in liposomes or micelles similarly enhances delivery by protecting the drug while exploiting tumor vessel permeability. Implanting drug-loaded beads or wafers directly into accessible tumors offers site-specific sustained release while avoiding systemic toxicity.
Technological solutions are also being harnessed. For example, low-intensity pulsed ultrasound creates pressure waves that transiently open the blood-brain barrier, allowing drugs to better penetrate brain tumors. Looking forward, emerging mathematical modeling approaches and patient-derived organoid assays aim to predict optimal tumor drug uptake for each patient and match to the best regimens. Advancing real-time imaging tracers, sensors, and biomarkers will help monitor drug delivery during treatment to inform adaptive dosing.
Combating solid tumors requires attacking from all sides. While obstructing access to most drugs, new immunotherapies like checkpoint inhibitors may actually help remodel the tumor architecture and vascularity in ways that open the floodgates. Scientists are also enthusiastically exploring synergistic multi-drug combinations, recognizing that overcoming numerous complementary resistance mechanisms simultaneously will be key. Like a complex puzzle, assembling the right pieces of drug delivery optimization, technology, immunotherapy, and combination therapy promises to gradually make substantial headway against cancer’s formidable defenses.
https://www.nature.com/articles/nrc1893 https://aacrjournals.org/clincancerres/article/11/24/8782/188867/The-Distribution-of-the-Anticancer-Drug https://medicalxpress.com/news/2023-05-chemotherapy-drug-brain-humans.html https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022519318303084 ttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0927776514007280 https://www.nature.com/articles/cddis2013350 https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/oncology/articles/10.3389/fonc.2021.640392/full
Natural Compounds to Overcome Tumor Drug Resistance
Emerging preclinical evidence suggests certain natural substances may harbor properties able to enhance delivery and efficacy of chemotherapy drugs against solid tumors. However, rigorous testing is still needed to verify if these effects translate to clinical outcomes.
For example, curcumin, a polyphenol compound from the spice turmeric, has exhibited abilities to suppress angiogenesis and reduce tumor hypoxia in preclinical cancer models. By normalizing the tumor vasculature and improving oxygenation, curcumin may be able to increase perfusion and penetration of certain chemotherapy drugs into the tumor tissue. Curcumin also reduces expression of anti-apoptotic proteins like NF-kB and AKT to make cancer cells more susceptible to chemotherapy-induced cell death.
Resveratrol, an antioxidant enriched in grapes and berries, has also been shown in preclinical studies to facilitate vessel normalization and oxygenation within the tumor microenvironment. By counteracting abnormalities in tumor vasculature and hypoxia, resveratrol may enhance drug delivery and efficacy.
Additionally, the green tea polyphenol EGCG demonstrates effects on stabilizing tumor blood vessels and reducing vessel leakiness in animal models. This vascular normalization could make drug delivery more precise and less heterogeneous. EGCG may also reverse chemotherapy resistance by altering epigenetic modifications in cancer cells.
Quercetin, a bioflavonoid found in fruits, vegetables and teas, has displayed activity in preclinical cancer models that could help enhance chemotherapy delivery and efficacy. Specifically, quercetin has exhibited an ability to inhibit the efflux pumps that eject chemotherapy agents from cancer cells, thereby increasing their retention and cytotoxic activity. Quercetin has also demonstrated effects on reducing tumor hypoxia and normalizing vasculature in some preclinical studies, which could improve perfusion.
Omega-3 fatty acids, especially EPA and DHA found in fish oil, have been shown to reduce elevated interstitial fluid pressure within tumors in animal models. By lowering this pressure which collapses blood vessels, omega-3 supplementation may be able to relieve vessel compression to improve drug delivery.
Extracts from the medicinal resin frankincense contain boswellic acids that may also enhance drug distribution. Boswellic acids appear to restrict angiogenesis and normalize tumor blood vessels based on limited preclinical evidence. This could slow aberrant vessel growth and improve perfusion.
Additionally, other natural compounds like genistein from soy, curcumin from turmeric, and sulforaphane from cruciferous vegetables have exhibited some early preclinical evidence of anti-angiogenic, pro-apoptotic, epigenetic modulating, or vasculature normalizing effects that could theoretically help counteract chemotherapy resistance. However, robust research in relevant tumor models and especially clinical trials are imperative to substantiate any benefit.
Overall, accumulating preclinical evidence supports further exploration of certain natural substances as potential adjuvants to standard chemotherapy. Their multifaceted effects on factors like tumor blood vessels, hypoxia, efflux pumps, and cellular signaling offer hope. But rigorous validation is needed to fully assess their ability to enhance outcomes for cancer patients.